For the last decade or so, one of the media’s favorite hobbyhorses is the idea that free speech in this country is acutely threatened by what you might call “the campus left”: a loose conglomeration of activists, professors, and bureaucrats who shout down campus speakers, police everyday speech, and dish out social and administrative punishment for anyone who steps out of line.

The amount of ink spilled on this has been incredible; dozens of milquetoast careers are floating in it. And yet now, to anyone with a functioning brain, it seems quaint. We are now witnessing an actual assault on free speech, backed with the force of the state, and initiated by people who harbor genuine disdain for the principles of the First Amendment. Protestors who committed no crime deported; law firms who represent Donald Trump’s enemies targeted with executive orders; congressmen who criticize Elon Musk threatened with prosecution; media organizations who don’t toe the line having their access limited; universities having their federal funding stripped for political reasons. 

And how were free speech advocates spending their time in the years leading up to this moment? The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), a prominent free speech advocacy group, was maintaining a database of “deplatforming attempts”: attempts to cancel or disrupt campus speech. Under their framework, anything from a single person’s petition to cancel a speaking event to a brief outburst of protest during a speech qualifies as a “deplatforming attempt.” Moreover, they count each speaker separately. So, for example, when a few protestors chanted “ceasefire now” at a Stanford University event last December before being escorted out, FIRE tallied six deplatforming attempts – one for each speaker. 

Even with this loose rubric, FIRE generally counts just a few dozen deplatforming attempts per year (with a notable uptick in 2024 given the nationwide Gaza protests). In a country with about 4500 degree-granting institutions of higher education, most of which consistently host speaking events, art showcases and so forth, what we’re talking about is at most one deplatforming attempt per every several thousand events.

In other words, while the American right loudly and publicly coalesced around its authoritarian impulses, self-described free speech advocates occupied themselves with trifling minutiae. The charitable view is that they were wasting their time. But the reality is a little darker: these groups weren’t just spinning their wheels, they were actively facilitating the right-wing campaign against free expression.

logo

Upgrade to premium!

Become a paying subscriber of String in a Maze to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

A subscription gets you:

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

t E1 year ago

The arrests really represent a quandary since those arrested unequivocally engaged in anti-Jewish hate speech but America’s lack of hate speech laws allowed such rhetoric to flourish in the first place. Strong hate speech laws would have likely killed Trump’s political career in its infancy. And with the people of Gaza now protesting Hamas, westerners support of the group are really just indulging in their own antisemitism. However due process should always be followed, so there’s no other way to see it than the protesters’ rights being violated, even if they shouldn’t have been allowed to disseminate hate speech in the first place.

Avatar

Jared M1 year ago

There’s no quandary—“anti-Jewish hate speech” is protected speech, full stop (also I take serious issue with your claim that all those arrested even did that, but that’s beside the point). The First Amendment means nothing if it doesn’t protect unpopular or even “hateful” speech.

Avatar

t E1 year ago

Yes, and I’m saying America’s lack of hate speech laws is idiotic and a major reason fascism was allowed to fester and eventually subsume the government. And, yes, the protesters were engaged in anti-Semitic hate speech by and large. Unfortunately for you, no perceived injustice provided a get out of jail free card for calling for the annihilation of a state and a people.

Avatar

Kay Oogamy1 year ago

About 10 years ago (can't believe it's been so long!) I went through that whole FIRE database of "successful deplatformings" and it ruined me. I just wanted to see if it was true that 'these attacks on free speech are coming FROM THE LEFT', since FIRE was claiming this everywhere. Of course, they were not. What I learned was that the majority of cancellations of left-wing speakers came from uni administrations, and the majority of right-wing cancellations were the right-wing speakers cancelling their own gigs. Yes, they pulled out of their own volition, and FIRE categorized them as "withdrawing in the face of protest".

At the time there were 3 categories - 1) Official cancellation from admin or inviting group 2) Heckler's vetoes 3) Cancellation in the face of protest - and they made it sound like 2) and 3) were basically the same, but they were not.

I still have the screenshots and notebook where I tallied this up. It still makes me sick. Sicker even seeing what's happening today.

Avatar

Jared M1 year ago

Protestors don’t get a pass just because they convinced an administrator to (likely illegally) cancel it instead of cancelling it themselves. And a self-cancellation is also extremely problematic if it’s done in response to, eg, bomb threats.