The case of Kilmar Abrego Garcia is probably the most viscerally grotesque thing the Trump administration has done, which is saying something. To recap:

  • The administration summarily deported several hundred men alleged to be Venezuelan gang members to a gulag in El Salvador, even as a federal judge told them to turn the plane around;

  • Everyone, the Trump administration included, agrees that at least one of these men, a Maryland resident named Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia, was mistakenly deported;

  • The Supreme Court ordered the Trump administration to “facilitate” the return of Abrego Garcia, but was careful not to require them to “effectuate” his return. In other words, Trump must attempt to have Abrego Garcia returned, but because El Salvador is a sovereign nation that could theoretically refuse to cooperate, he’s not required to ensure it actually happens.

The Supreme Court’s ruling was wildly dangerous because it gives Trump permission to lie: he can very easily claim that he tried and failed to have Abrego Garcia returned, even if he never did.

logo

Upgrade to premium!

Become a paying subscriber of String in a Maze to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

A subscription gets you:

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Cooper Napoles1 year ago

Fascism is not a sudden jump. First Trump subverted SCOTUS, then they empowered him, now hes ignoring them. There won't be a day when they go "too far" and people(on either side) will finally rise to action. It is a slow deliberate march. There isn't going to be a "time for action" which spurs everyone in this mass movement; the time is --and has been-- now.

Avatar

t E1 year ago

My big thing is how many more have been picked up like this but had no one to advocate for them?

Avatar

Kevin Choubacha1 year ago

The biggest surprise to me is that they aren’t even lying about making an effort. They are doubling down on him and even saying they will deport him again if he were to be returned.

I actually thought Trump and co would lie and say they asked etc. but they didn’t!!! They are adding more made up allegations such as human trafficking!!!

Hard to laugh when the social contract is torn asunder.

Avatar

Matthew Stuart1 year ago

Having listened to so much 5-4, as a non lawyer, it was so damn frustrating seeing the standard SCOTUS-sucking media just gloss through the court's bad faith attempt at hoping Trump wouldn't choose this battle. They gave him a nudge saying "come on, just this one," and of course he wouldn't. They gave him the ingredients in the 2024 immunity ruling and are now surprised he's baking a cake that says "i won't heed the judiciary."

Imagine being a legal analyst who was surprised that Stephen Miller would be so callous and lawless in his pursuit of hurting brown people.